August 12, 2008

Fallows vs Brooks

And it's no contest: James Fallows dismantles David Brooks' column on China. His advice:

Take a little time and look around, David. The parts that don't fit what you theorized before arriving are actually the most stimulating.

That's in response to Brook's beloved pseudo-scientific hucksterism:

If you show an American an image of a fish tank, the American will usually describe the biggest fish in the tank and what it is doing. If you ask a Chinese person to describe a fish tank, the Chinese will usually describe the context in which the fish swim.

These sorts of experiments have been done over and over again, and the results reveal the same underlying pattern. Americans usually see individuals; Chinese and other Asians see contexts.

12 Aug 2008 15:28:59 | China

1 Comment

dearieme

We in Britain would describe both the Wood and the trees. Well I would.

Posted by: dearieme | August 12, 2008 at 06:29 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.

NEXT POST
Capello's Common Sense More evidence emerges that England selected the right man when they asked Fabio Capello to rescue their football team. From the Times today: On another issue - Wayne Rooney's smoking habit - Capello was curiously indifferent, a stance that brought out sweat beads on the foreheads of his FA employers, fearful of their manager unwittingly being cast as the spokesman for a generation of English butt-heads. Capello later returned to clarify his position and the moral guardians were headed off at the pass... Capello's lack of interest in making a judgment revealed that the difference between football people in Europe and Britain is not merely a matter of tactics or technique. The fact is, smoking is not seen as the great taboo for a sportsman abroad that it is here. Johan Cruyff smoked heavily, so did Socrates, of Brazil, and Slaven Bilic, the Croatia coach, has been known to spark one up on the touchline. Last year, Bilic admitted being amused during his days with West Ham United and Everton that English players would react in horror when he lit up during social gatherings. “Then they would drink so much that they could not stand up,” he said. “Where I...
PREVIOUS POST
The Kosovan Connection There's not much point in arguing with Andy McCarthy, but National Review's resident pop-eyed frother-and-splutterer-in-chief has this to say today: the recognition of Kosovo was a huge blunder, forced by those who think Muslim agitators will like us better, rather than sense weakness, if we appease and break the rules for them. On what planet was this the argument for recognising Kosovo?

alex massie

Search

My Online Status

Recent Comments