The little white rose of Scotland which smells sharp and sweet and breaks the heart

As part of its rather odd Call Yourself British campaign The Daily Telegraph has sent the novelist Andrew O'Hagan to tour the country and take its temperature. There'll be plenty to say about this over the next few days. But, beginning in Edinburgh, O'Hagan writes:

Despite the work of centuries, an intellectual Enlightenment, an Industrial Revolution, the formation and decline of Empire, and two world wars, Scotland still feels nervous of its relationship with England, the same nervousness that Defoe objected to and hoped might     have come to an end as he walked up the High Street in the 1720s. But to make that journey today is to fall into step with the revival of an old song: when will the Union be over?

I arrived in Edinburgh with what might be called a natural resistance to the conditions of that song. Britain is a small series of islands; we have achieved much together; and to be a unity, while retaining our distinctive character, seems to me a beautiful idea.

I am Scottish and I grew up believing – in the face of superstition, and chants – that England and Scotland brought out the best in one another. I find it easy to be both Scottish and British, happily dualistic, and small nations being excessively proud of themselves (a new European habit) has no special fascination. It seems as lunatic to me as the argument of Southern Confederates in  America, who feel they were betrayed by Abraham Lincoln.

But the old song wasn't about the survival of the Union, but about Scotland's survival as an independent nation. After all, ideas for Union had been bandied about for hundreds of years before the formal dissolution of the Scots parliament in 1707. (That is, the idea of Union bubbled up from time to time independently of the - tiresome - English desire for incorporation.)

Also: who are these small nations that are "excessively proud of themselves"? Are no large nations afflicted by this sin? Or are they entitled to their pride? Must small nations be inherently ridiculous? Rum. And hooey.

Still, it's more interesting that O'Hagan links the modern independence cause with the Confederacy. This isn't quite as odd as it might seem at first blush (though I'd also suggest that if it is impossible to leave a Union then that Union is, ipso facto, to some degree coercive rather than voluntary).

It's certainly the case, if I may generalise, that American conservatives tend to be more interested in Scotland than liberals. I should have ceased to be surprised by the number of Americans (and other foreigners) who say they are waiting for Scottish independence. Many, perhaps most, of these sympathisers are conservatives.

In part this may reflect the settlement patterns of Scots in the Carolinas and Appalachia which these days ensures that those most likely to appreciate their Scottish heritage are also, on balance, more likely to be conservatives than liberals. But it's also the case that the idea of Scotland has a cultural resonance in the south - or amongst some conservatives - that it lacks in New England.

Granted, it was the Californian John Steinbeck who told Jackie Kennedy (of all people!), “You talked of Scotland as a lost cause and that is not true. Scotland is an unwon cause.” But his sentiments are in tune with a romantic view of Scotland's history that has something in common with a certain view of the American south and, perhaps, a certain wistful strain of American conservatism.

That's the view that's encouraged by the (loathsome) Braveheart  - a movie which has become a favourite of whatever remains of what one might term the neo-Confederate movement. 

More positively, one might recall that Sir Walter Scott was the most popular novelist in the antebellum south. That should not be a great surprise: on the one hand a novel such as Ivanhoe could appeal to southern ideas of chivalry; on the other Scott's Scottish novels concern the struggle to marry tradition with modernity and to find a union between past and present that satisfies the memory of the past with the demands of the present day. Progress might be inevitable and, on balance, a good thing, but it can be a melancholy business that tears the heart, accompanied, of course, by the strains of an old lament.

So from whence springs the conservative fascination with Scotland? Steinbeck is only half right; it's not merely that Scotland is unwon but the conditions that create the need for an old lament that matter. The particular poignancy of the Scottish cause - and why it has a surprising power outside of Scotland, not merely in the United States but in France or Germany too - stems, I think, from the fact that, contrary to popular imagination, it was a cause that was given up more or less voluntarily. It didn't have to happen. There's  poignancy to that melancholy reflection. One may go so far as to approve the result of the Jacobite wars even whole regretting the manner in which it was done (and they were, of course, Scottish civil wars as much as they were a matter of Scotland vs England).

In other words, the Jacobite cause is reactionary in the best sense of the term (and proudly so: I have one American froend whose personal email address begins, jacobite1688). To some extent this remains the case. The atavistic nationalism O'Hagan discovers is far removed from the sober calculation of the national interest favoured by the SNP's smart-suited Young Turks in Edinburgh. Yet the latter requires the former, even if the former cannot prevail absent the latter.

All this may seem some way removed from modern Scotland. But it isn't really. The age-old wrestling match between heart and head has not been resolved yet. Or rather, to be accurate, it has been rejoined.

There's much more to be said, of course (I haven't even touched on Brigadoon though it obviously is linked to the matter under discussion). But I'd be interested in what Messrs Larison and Douthat have to say about any of this.

Comments

[Andrew]

Alex: have been preoccupied chasing birds with the dogs -- and have been remiss in checking in. But how very nice to see a wee smidgeon of Hugh MacDiarmid -- and a few cogent thoughts as well.

How was 'Black Watch'?

Andrew

[cp]

To be honest, this sort of thing doesn't endear America to Britons such as myself. What business is it of yours to go around the place idly wishing to abolish and reorganise my country, and all in the name of some selfish, faint, remote and vague pinings? I support the Iraq and Afstan engagements to the hilt, but I begin to believe there is something to this notion of clumsy American imperialism, and I do not like it one bit.

America and Americans have no business stirring up more problems in the UK. You did enough of that with Ireland. And before that, with India, and all the rest of it, after the war. Fuck off. The end.

[Gallowglass]

Answering CP: in both World Wars, the British Empire spent a great deal of money and effort to get the Great Republic to enter the Wars on OUR side.

And nowadays, Southern Death Rows are infested with Clive Stafford-Smith types trying to persuade Americans not to kill their most loathsome criminals.

So, we interfere(d) in their politics, they interfere in ours. Deal.

[Gallowglass]

I'd forgotten how much of a diddy Andrew O'Hagan is. Confederates never felt "betrayed" by Lincoln - they knew him for what he was, an open enemy, avowed for years, whnich is why they bombarded Sumter as soon as he was elected.

[Keith]

Confederacy uniquely accommodates pro-Independence and pro-Union preferences. Perhaps thats why we hear so little of it from on high...yet.

[roy]

Andre youd be speaken german if not for the ameircan mind your toug have repect

[brian t]

re the Scottish heritage in the USA, I was surprised to see no mention of Texas, despite the Scots origin of city names like Houston, Austin, and Dallas. On the TV show "Dallas", the Ewing family - Scots again - was headed by "Jock"!

[Nick Matyas]

Its really nice post....
I was searching this kind of posting .....
I just liked it....
Thanks....

webroyalty

[generic viagra]

all sports are fun as long as people remember that they are games, physical activity is good for the body and the recreational part distracts you from work everyday!

[generic viagra]

all sports are fun as long as people remember that they are games, physical activity is good for the body and the recreational part distracts you from work everyday!

[bangbros]

But the old song wasn't about the survival of the Union, but about Scotland's survival as an independent nation. After all, ideas for Union had been bandied about for hundreds of years before the formal dissolution of the Scots parliament in 1707

[refurbished computers]

Its ergonomic design and optimized key spacing make working and communicating a much more pleasurable and productive experience, with fewer errors and faster typing speeds.

[viagra online]

Hi, I love your design and am interested in learning more about how the project is going.
This is just the most wonderful house I have seen ever, absolutely brilliant. Kepp up the good work.

[generic augmentin]

Confederacy uniquely accommodates pro-Independence and pro-Union preferences. Perhaps thats why we hear so little of it from on high...yet.

[cheap adalat]

A healthcare provider may prescribe Adalat CC to treat high blood pressure in adults. Although Adalat CC does not cure high blood pressure, it can help control it and can decrease the risk of developing health problems associated with long-term high blood pressure. Adalat CC works by relaxing the blood vessels to improve blood flow. Some off-label Adalat CC uses include treating preterm labor, the hiccups, and chest pain.

[buy viagra onlin]

But the old song wasn't about the survival of the Union, but about

[Chanel outlet]

"Blessed is the man who expects nothing, for he shall not be disap-pointed."

-----Alexander Pope. British Poet

[belstaff]

2005 was first released on the Interbrand global best brand list in 2006, ZARA standings after Adidas, brand value of 42.35 billion dollars. ZARA every one of the store manager has a custom pdas, through this computer networking PDA they can order directly to headquarters, and headquarters can directly between master every store sales, and store manager can also communicate with our headquarters product manager. Such ZARA can do design, production and delivery in 15 days to complete. The harvard business review says: ZARA established a different from traditional industries of communication supply chain. This is the supply chain help ZARA completed its 15 days myth. In ZARA you can always find new products, and is a limited supply. These goods are most is placed by the special shelves above. This temporary goods-stopping strategy in many people's eyes too bold! But think about all limited supply goods on the market by enthusiasts right, people need not product but "extraordinary", "unique". ZARA temporary goods-stopping and satisfying the people's psychology, ZARA because the subversive practice slowly become one-of-a-kind spokesperson. http://www.belstaffstoreonline.com/

[Canada Goose]

Prefer Canada Goose Jackets in Canada Goose, more experience for winter life !
With winter coming, the Goose Down Jacket Canada and Women Canada Goose Chiliwack Parka BLACK with authentic quality will be the best choice for you.

Winter coming, everyone is starting to shop around for a warm winter coat. But the big question is: which one will keep you the warmest without making you look like an abominable snowman? Today´s article highlights for you two coats that meet these important criteria: Canada Goose Men's Yorkville Bomber and Canada Goose Outlet Trillium by Canadian Goose.

From Canada Goose Sale, Canada Goose Parka inspired by the label´s iconic Canada Goose Women Expedition design. It´s fitted with plenty of internal and external pockets as well as a versatile removable down filled hood, secure Velcro collar and storm flap protection over the front zipper. The cut is a bit slimmer than we´re used to seeing on vests and outerwear pieces alike, which definitely works in your favor when traveling from work to play and vice versa.

[Cat Boots]

CAT Footwear is the world's leading footwear companies in the rankings. They are an experienced, when it comes to make Cat Shoes and Cat Boots, they are proud of the Caterpillar brand owners and their mission is to provide the market with the latest developments in the shoe department of a comfortable, durable shoes. Their area of expertise in their shoes, Caterpillar Boots with special features is just to make sure every footwear will be comfortable to wear as the first priority. Some models have steel toes, and some do not, they have given, to some extent, the inner surface can easily be removed, put back some of the special archs orthopedic support, not slippery. Surprising to know that these features bootshave to prevent electric shock, and thermal insulation of the action.

There are Ladies Caterpillar Boots, while other prominent women's shoes, Caterpillar will be moving within the raised floor, allowed the wearer to replace the floor the other Mens Cat Boots. Orthotics are custom. These boots will provide comfort and protection, women were not the case. Whether you want to put your shoes when working or when you are climbing, this is the best choice, you can. Women's Caterpillar Shoes in different designs, and provide price will vary depending on your choice. ...

[Belstaff Jackets]

welcome to my site

[Careprost]

Hola,
Ha hecho un trabajo muy bueno. Hay muchas personas en busca de eso ahora van a encontrar suficientes fuentes por tus consejos.
espera para obtener más consejos acerca de que

[belstaffclothing]

Belstaff tote 556 Features:with greater quality and correct to fashion design, belstaffsell.com.belstaff jackets are appreciated for their outstanding quality and elegant appearance. However, these high-priced materials. Therefore, we are able to not be negligent within the election. Ultimately,the quality of one's research for the most effective article toujours.Dans quality and never on other aspects, the end.

[VimaX]

I am thoroughly convinced in this said post. I am currently searching for ways in which I could enhance my knowledge in this said topic you have posted here. It does help me a lot knowing that you have shared this information here freely. I love the way the people here interact and shared their opinions too. I would love to track your future posts pertaining to the said topic we are able to read.

[plantronics wireless headset]

Scottish history is so rich and taken very serious in their culture. This information here just empowers those thoughts.

[plantronics telephone headset]

I agree here with this author. All points are very clear and understood.