"Socialism in one clause"?

Peter Hoskin is right to be suspicious of the government's latest ploy: mandating that all public bodies have a statutory duty to narrow the gap between rich and poor. As you might expect Polly Toynbee is tickled a deepish shade of red by the notion. Nonetheless, consider this snippet from her column today:

Poor children might need to have much more spent on their education per head than the better-off do. Sure Start toddlers might need more funds than older children. It might mean local lotteries to see that all children get equal access to the best schools.

It's a myth, of course, that simply ploughing more money into schools necessarily improves them and I suspect that Toynbee envisions some centralised system whereby bureaucrats allocate funds based on some incomprehensible and inflexible formula. Still, it wouldn't have to be that way: giving head-teachers greater license to spend their school budget as they see fit (and thus freeing them from LEAs) would be a good start. If that means they want to spend more on salaries to attract better teachers then fine.

More significantly, Toynbee seems to be endorsing greater school choice. That's a good thing. The current system of "slection by house price" is inequitable for sure. But the best way to organise "local lotteries" for access to the best schools is to permit all parents to choose the school they want their kids to attend. Parents should decide what is the best school for their kids, not civil servants. A lottery would only be necessary if and when a school is over-subscribed. If I recall correctly, New Zealand's school choice system results in more than 75% of parents getting their kids into their preferred school. There's no great reason to suppose some similarly happy outcome could be achieved in Britain. School choice incentivises parents to be more involved with their kids' education and, as we know, parental involvement is one of the most important factors in determining educational success.

Comments

[Dave Weeden]

Whoa! "giving head-teachers greater license to spend their school budget as they see fit". Hold on, that implies that head-teachers have a fixed budget - so more money on salaries means less money elsewhere. Now Socrates (who may have been one of the most inspired *adult* teachers in history) 'taught' outdoors, without books (also, LEAs take note, for free). Ditto Jesus. So, I suppose, schools could crumble, and good teachers could prevail. But I don't think the budget is *that* plastic. There are buildings to maintain (and they're the property of the LEA; collapse due to neglect is a budget loss), there are kids to feed ...

I mean, I see your logic. I just don't think it works while LEAs control budgets. Heads don't have that much freedom. I walked to school, and I'd hope my kids (if I ever have any) can do the same. We have local democracy for this. Why is democracy sexy abroad, but apparently stinky when it comes to local issues?

[ZX]

The trouble with applying to the school of your choice, is that many people's choice is instantly restricted by financial factors. Pupils need to get to schools, whether by car, bus, or train, and only those who are middle class (and therefor already statistically more likely to succeed) can afford the time/money to car, bus, or train their little darlings to Robert Gordon's College five days a week.

[ally]

So in any given year, you think that 25% of kids not getting their preferred school is fine? Really?

[E cig]

Thanks for the article!

[cheap computers]

I am happy to read your blog and admit the webmaster has done a very good job by putting all the information content at one place. I'd like to recommend it with reference to my website http://www.pctechoutlet.com

[Web Hosting]

It’s really great post. I would like to appreciate your work and would like to tell to my friends.

[auto dvd]

Interesting take on this issue.

[coach suitcase]

If you lose you way, Your forever friend guides you and cheers you on. Your forever friend holds your hand and tells you that everything is going to be okay.

[car dvd players]

I'd hope my kids can do the same. We have local democracy for this.

[jordan 11]

Mishaps are like knives that either serve us or cut us as we grasp them by the handle or blade. Do you understand?

[Lara]

Thank you for this good article! I can recommend you a good search engine on rapidshare files ( http://www.filecatch.com/trends/dk/03-08-2010.html )

[big boobs]

Thanks for such a great post and the review, I am totally impressed! Keep stuff like this coming.

[michael jordan]

I just loved it. Keep up the good work.

[ugg bailey button]

Some people pretend to despise the things they cannot have.So belive yourself.

[MLB Hats]

These are wonderful! Thank you for sharing
MLB Hats
Perhaps this is one of the most interesting blogs that I have ever seen. Interesting article, Funny comment. Keep it up!

[ruwenrong]

p>For half century, Canada Goose Jackets has been producing authentic extreme weather gear born of purpose and function, Canada Goose Parka designed for those who need the confidence that come from quality. In Canada Goose Toronto beginning with a modest line of jackets and woolen shirts created in a small warehouse. Canada Goose Canada today has grown to be recognized internationally as the leading manufacturer of extreme weather outerwear in the world. We’ve kept our production at home in Canada because we believe that no one can do it better – but our products enjoy a truly global reach.

Canada Goose sale is equally at home in the weather research stations of the frigid South Pole as it is on the windswept Iditarod dog sledding trial in Alaska, Canada Goose Chilliwack on movie sets in remote locations around the world, and in the most exclusive high-fashion centers. Wherever people need protection from the elements, top quality and iconic style, you’ll find Canada Goose Coats.
People who love the outdoor lifestyle, and surfers and outdoor lovers have been wearing Canada Goose Jakke for well over fifty years on the place, as a way of keeping their body warm whilst out of the house.

[ruwenrong]

Well-known linguist Greg Thomson said: Rosetta Stone Reviews“Foreign Language Learning theory is so complicated that no one can say clearly; but have mastered the language of the process is so simple, so do not say.” To discuss language learning principle, is a very complex thing, the next course, not sure to describe clearly.Rosetta Stone French Reviews And because even the academic language learning there are many sharp arguments, I sure can not say their dispute resolved. But decided to start with a simple start, start a discussion of work to do it, to explore the essence of foreign language learning Rosetta Stone Discount UK , especially for people in foreign language learning to analyze common misunderstandings and to clarify, hoping to help foreign language Rosetta Stone Language, on teaching a foreign language to inspire, to satisfied. Over the years I have been to all universities, enterprises and other English language learners of English learning to do lectures. When speaking never sensational, never by performing stunts, do not engage in motivational Rosetta Stone spanish, each will give you a serious scientific basis. Million listeners over the past five years, is still relatively popular, of which a considerable part Rosetta Stone Torrent of the people can fully understand and agree with and made a lot of acute problems and improvements, to express deep gratitude.Rosetta Stone Italian Many people had advised the next lecture in this capacity, the sensational style to agitation type, popular in the country and will be able to accumulate wealth Rosetta Stone Software Download . I am not interested in names, or would have done so. Do not want to talk nonsense and fraught. As for the wealth you, do not like,Fake Watches, but have more than enough. So I am very lucky to get rid of money worries can now get down to reading Rosetta Stone Online and thinking. Now part of the speech before the sort made here, I hope, and our discussion.

[ruwenrong]

Then there are Skechers Shape Ups, which are pretty similar to the MBTs: “rocker” sole, big wedge of material under the heel to “promote natural walking,” deliberate instability.Skechers Shoes They tighten abs, firm butts, and destroy cellulite. Armed with the Skechers Shape-Ups, folks can “get fit without stepping in a gym.” I’ll agree Skechers UK that a gym isn’t necessary for fitness, but strapping on a pair of magic non-shoes and standing there, or walking around the mall hoping for artificial instability to kick in won’t do it. This revolutionary barefoot technology, Skechers Shape Ups Jump Startaccording to its hawkers, compels the wearer to move. Walking and exercising become almost Skechers Boots passive acts; the shoes apparently propel you down the street. All you’ve gotta do is be carried away on a couple of foot clouds. Heck, even Skechers Shape Ups Reviews standing at rest in these babies is a constant, imperceptibly effective workout for your entire body. Who needs to consciously work out anymore? Maybe the absurdity of barefoot technology isn’t evident to everyone, though. Condemning Skechers Boots Tone Ups a non-shoe that’s actually a shoe for claiming to recreate the barefoot experience seems “reasonable”, but it’s always good to back arguments up with empirical data. And all the barefoot tech peddlers claim to have research supporting their products,Skechers Shoes Discount so it’s only fair that we on the “nay” side also use research Bosu ball addicts have successfully integrated balls into many facets of everyday life.

[Cat Boots]

CAT Footwear is the world's leading footwear companies in the rankings. They are an experienced, when it comes to make Cat Shoes and Cat Boots, they are proud of the Caterpillar brand owners and their mission is to provide the market with the latest developments in the shoe department of a comfortable, durable shoes. Their area of expertise in their shoes, Caterpillar Boots with special features is just to make sure every footwear will be comfortable to wear as the first priority. Some models have steel toes, and some do not, they have given, to some extent, the inner surface can easily be removed, put back some of the special archs orthopedic support, not slippery. Surprising to know that these features bootshave to prevent electric shock, and thermal insulation of the action.

There are Ladies Caterpillar Boots, while other prominent women's shoes, Caterpillar will be moving within the raised floor, allowed the wearer to replace the floor the other Mens Cat Boots. Orthotics are custom. These boots will provide comfort and protection, women were not the case. Whether you want to put your shoes when working or when you are climbing, this is the best choice, you can. Women's Caterpillar Shoes in different designs, and provide price will vary depending on your choice. ...

[Truck Insurance companies]

great info. i will be comign

[cl boots]

I find life an exciting business,The point is succinctness of expression.

[sikiş]

duramıyo.. türk porno porno izle kökleim ohhhhh diye öyle bi inlediki hala nefesni hissediyorum kadının hızlı sikiş hızlı öyle bisikiş izle siktimki durmuyodum porno hiç.. okadar sert ve hızlı gitgellerim vardı kadın ucuyodu zevkten inliyodu göznden zevk gözyasları akıodu...2_3 kez bosaldı kadın.ama uzatamazdık fazla vakt yoktu cıkardım travesti travesti yaragımı ve göbeğine bosaldım .en kısa zama tekrar eve alıp ucurmak

[GHD hair nz]

Canada Goose Parka successfully launched a strong down jacket in Canada, Canada Goose Jackets that had weak to reproduce industry booming momentum; the Canada Goose Sale first proposed the new concept of sports, Canada Goose Coatsleisure and fashion, soCanada Goose Mens Parka make the winter clothes become "light, thin, beautiful" conversion Cheap Canada Goose Jackets is "thick, heavy, swollen" originally. GHD Hair Straighteners NZ, use the advanced technology, unique design style, novel style, rich and colorful product color, beautiful black series GHD Hair Straightenerin any circumstances is your perfect hairstyle stylist and Christmas good gift. The device irons of GHD NZare equipped with high integrated circuits, href="http://www.ghdhairstraightenersnz.org/">GHD New Zealandcovers aluminum .Welcome toUgg Boots, theUgg Australiaare very popular in the world and there are kinds of Cheap Ugg Shoes Salesale with great discount now.

[headphone]

Great entry, which everyone should be interested.

[bluetooth headphones]

Finally, an issue that I am passionate about.

[Pandora could be present in antithetical clues, flowers together with animal imprints, representations, zodiac indicators, colors in conjunction with substances that give you unlimited selections besides combination.In relation to Pandora Jewellery , the]

Pandora may perhaps be within antithetical clues, flowers plus animal imprints, representations, zodiac indicators, colors as well as substances that give you unlimited selections together with combination.Relating to Pandora Jewellery , the beads shift freely additionally rotate slightly with your wrists motion, creating the undeniable observation catching in combination with stunning influence.Pandora Bracelets has granted women globally the to be able to wear their personal report to lifes wonderful moments, thereby become component of their amazing story about romantic besides fun moments forever. Because Pandora style may very well be so private and distinctive, it can be a trend among women all over the world. Pandora bracelet fans emerge from worldwide and variety Pandora Necklace holics clubs or associations for exhibit their want to the irresistible gifts when using the gods.

[uzamax]

UZAMAX content of minerals and vitamins containing a natural food supplement made bitkielerden. Although there is the content of any chemical product is completely natural, dried vegetable mixture. Just a few months of use, even after cure uzamax'ın will feel the impact.

[Wholesalers]

Thanks for a great post and interesting comments.keep good working.

[Wholesale]

It was a very nice idea! good points.

[iphone 4 accessories]

I agree with you, your saying is so good and usful for me. keep this good working.

[MBT M.Walk]

Today really don't strike you! WenJianXin! No, no! Is HanJianXin! I today if not strike you! "You seem following me! Haha! Silly wench." Sword Xin ran aside even now does not overlook to return overdo to induce me. Damn it!

[air max bw femme]

simply ploughing more money into schools necessarily improves them and I suspect that Toynbee envisions some centralised system whereby bureaucrats allocate funds based on some incomprehensible and inflexible formula. Still, it wouldn't have to be that way: giving head-teachers greater license to spend their school budget as they see fit (and thus freeing them from LEAs) would be a good start. If that means they want to spend more on salaries to attract better teachers then fine

[jianxiu blog]

ploughing more money into schools necessarily improves them and I suspect that Toynbee envisions some centralised system whereby casquette red bull bureaucrats allocate funds based on some incomprehensible and inflexible formula. Still, it wouldn't have to be that way: giving head-teachers greater license to spend their school budget as they see fit (and thus freeing them from LEAs) would be a good start. If that means they want to spend more on salaries to attract better teachers then fine.

[Jack wills]

Nice one, there is actually some good points on this blog some of my readers may find this useful, I must send a link, many thanks!.

[hollister uk]

There is noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made sure nice points in features also.!!

[Jack wills]

I think am just having some problems with subscribing to RSS feed here.
!

[3ds flash card]

Amazing resource!! Charities are benefiting more and more from social networking and this article really accentuates that.

[oakley sunglasses]

Yum! Even the pharmaceutical industry, historically tied to long-term investment cycles, cut 69,000 jobs in 2009, up 60% from 2008:)

[hollister clothing]

The game's a lot less fun when you're not playing too. Equally clearly this move wouldn't be happening without the support and encouragement of those of you who read this blog and those of you who have been kind enough to link here. So for that, many thanks.

[Laptop Computers]

I have read nearly all the posts on your blog and I would to continue but I terribly want to sleep. It’s 4 a.m.

[Franklin and Marshall]

After read the article.I have just one word to say,you are so brilliant.I like all of your article.Well done.

[MBT Shoes]

Good work!I would look forword your article.

[Coach Outlet Store]

cheers for the crazy content on your blog, I am very curious in this post and you have really helped me. I have just told a few of my friends about this on FaceBook and they love your content just as much as I do.

[birkenstock outlet]

It would be as absurd as it would be Wi ked for him to attempt to

[North Face Outlet]

ascending limb of Ilenlc's loop. This 'medullary anginal syndrome* is a possible cause of apoptosis for part of the parenchyma which had not undergone to pre-vious necrosis, i.e. the

[ray ban sonnenbrillen]

ray ban sonnenbrillen

[thomas sabo]

thomas sabo

[true religion jeans]

true religion jeans

[peinture à l'huile]

peinture à l'huile

[Casque Monster]

Casque Monster