Kudos to Frank Foer for alerting one to this priceless passage from David Gelernter's most recent article in the Weekly Standard:
Granting the importance of the topic, the difference in moral stature
between presidential candidates has rarely been as enormous as it is
today--not (or not only) because Obama's is so small but because
McCain's is so large. There is no single English word for McCain the
hero, the moral entity. But in Hebrew he would be called a tsaddik--a
man of such nobility and moral substance that he approaches holiness.
If this assertion sounds crazy, that only shows how little we have
thought about the issue.
OK, we'll have to go away and think about it. Mr Gelernter concludes:
"Who shall ascend the mountain of the Lord? Or who shall stand in
His holy place? He that hath clean hands, and a pure heart" (Psalm
24:3-4). Whether you like or dislike his politics, that is John McCain
all over. If he wins this election, it will be a come-from-behind
surprise. But in larger American terms, it will be no surprise at all.
I mean, Jesus. Really. Extraordinary.
UPDATE: Commenter JHB has a terrifying question. Terrifying, that is, if it were ever answered in the affirmative: "Now here's a challenge: do you think you could find someone who feels that way about Gordon Brown?"
It's not really any dafter than some of the adulation that Obama has received. It's just that McCain has been around long enough that it's hard to have illusions about him. Well, maybe that does make Gelernter whackier than the Obama-worshipers, who have a blanker canvas on which to paint their fantasies. Now here's a challenge: do you think you could find someone who feels that way about Gordon Brown?
Posted by: Jim | October 27, 2008 at 07:04 PM
I particularly liked Gelernter's moral equivalence between John McCain and Soviet dissident turned ultra-rightwing Israeli nutcase Natan Sharansky.
Posted by: ndm | October 27, 2008 at 07:43 PM